Cookies!

We use cookies to improve your browsing experience. And dolphins make us happy. Find out more about our cookies policy here.

The Best Fishing Boat Rentals in Fire Island

Browse, book, and get out onto the water with local fishing guides and boat owners.

Our Favorite Fishing Boat Rentals in Fire Island

Powerboats in Gilgo-Oak Beach-Captree · 8 guests
Cruise in style with this Spacious 30ft Chris Craft Catalina Boat
New
$425/hour
Fishing in Fire Island · 6 guests
Fishing and Clamming Trip onboard the 23ft Parker Sport Cabit Boat
New
$325/hour
Powerboats in Islip · 6 guests
Perfect Day Boat to Cruise , Swim and just RELAX!! FUEL INCLUDED!
New
$150/hour
Fishing in Islip · 5 guests
Come Enjoy A Day Of Fishing Or Relaxation Onboard Reel Serenity 2 (FUEL INCLUDE)
New
$150/hour

Suggested Searches

This weekend $100-$300 trips 2-4 people Captained

Types of Boats Popular in Fire Island

Top Fishing Boat Rental Locations Near Fire Island

Long Island, New York
70 listings

Most Popular Yacht Rentals in Fire Island

Powerboats in Fire Island · 18 guests
Tiki Boat Cruise to Fire Island for up to 18 people
5.0
$500/hour
Travel in Bay Shore · 12 guests
Cruising South Shore of Long Island in Class
New
$600/hour
Events in Patchogue · 6 guests
56’ Motor Yacht Rental in Patchogue, New York
5.0
$375/hour
Instant Book
Events in Fire Island · 6 guests
Fire Island Fishing And Sand Bar Adventure
New
$350/hour

Most Popular Boat Tours in Fire Island

Events in Bay Shore · 6 guests
Best Island Experience: Fire Island - Bay Shore
5.0
$140+/hour

Top Fishing Boat Rental Locations in the United States

How To Book on Getmyboat

4.9 out of 5! • 500,000+ reviews

Browse
Find the right listing for you and your crew, with options for boat types, group size, captained or self-charter, and lots more.
Inquire & Book
Found one you like? Send a rental inquiry with your preferred trip details, and you’ll receive an offer from your captain to book.
Enjoy
Coordinate a pick-up place and time, meet your boat captain, and get out onto the water!

Real reviews from happy Getmyboaters.

4.9 out of 5! 500,000+ reviews

© Getmyboat 2025